I have shared prompts and views about evaluating mutual funds beyond simple categories or recent returns. These posts capture questions and evaluation principles, not supporting data or specific fund recommendations. My discussion of consistency and longer-term fund comparisons also connects to rolling returns and consistency.
I shared “A perspective on whether size matters in mutual funds,” but the captured fragment gives no conclusion about whether size matters or what size means.
I wrote, “we need move beyond the buckets of active vs. passive” and “start understanding funds for what they are individually - good or bad.”
I said, “There are brilliant active funds out there, and terrible passive ones.”
I also said, “The reverse is also true.”
I said, “more rigour needs to be applied in looking at the index behind the fund.”
- When assessing an index behind a fund, I named “Construct, methodology, valuations, weighting, market cap exposure.”
I cautioned, “It isn't as simple as buying an index fund based on last 1 or 3 year returns.”
I commented on a post by @avasthiniranjan: “Very interesting data.” The captured post does not include the data or further comment from me.
I introduced a post with the words “MF returns in a 2 year period when markets have been flat”; the captured text supplies no returns comparison or result.
The captured material does not specify which mutual-fund size measure the first prompt concerns, provide examples of funds or indexes, or give evidence behind the comments on expense ratios and flat-market returns.
Related: active versus passive investing, evaluating sif strategies, index and target maturity funds