I strongly recommend that I do not compare and sort SIFs on returns; I focus on what the SIF is doing, what risk it is taking, and whether it is delivering against that.
I note that funds in the same category have different approaches; I ask how returns appeared and why.
I give the example that a small SIF of 100 cr. can show quick returns through 1-2 cr anchor positions in IPOs or small deals, but this is not scalable at size.
I conclude that better questions lead to better experience.
A quoted post by @moneycontrolcom reports SIF returns of up to 16% in 10 months and says these products are designed to offer greater flexibility and access to more sophisticated investment strategies. Those are claims from the quoted account, not results I independently report.
I call the linked material a sensible take on how to compare SIFs in the hybrid category; I encouraged @KirtanShahCFP to continue producing similar work.
I appreciate the focus on investing in hybrid SIFs with a 18+ month horizon.
I say, “This is a very relevant point about SIFs.”
The post quotes @itsdeepakjain, whose discussion frames the subject as “SIF - Strategy, Performance & Evaluation.” The quoted account says strategy should align with objectives and contrasts performance-based sorting of vanilla mutual funds with the difficulty of comparing SIFs whose strategies differ. Its point about comparison based primarily on NAV movement ends mid-thought, so the intended conclusion is unavailable.
I use this page to record my guidance on evaluating SIFs: compare the specific solution, construction, risks, and investor experience rather than assuming category labels or headline returns tell the whole story.
In my 2025-09-30 post, I said Altiva Hybrid Long Short, our first SIF, opens tomorrow and shared general thoughts on the category.
I said there is no standard answer for what return a SIF can deliver because it depends on the category and the particular product.
I said SIFs in the same category can differ substantially; a 75-25 long-short fund and a 25-25 long-short fund can have very different risk-return profiles, so comparisons should be nuanced and funds should not be sorted by returns.
I identify SIF’s core flexibility as derivative usage beyond the hedging allowed in MF, which can support products with lower market exposure and risk and better risk-adjusted returns.
I describe SIF as a solution rather than an asset class: investors should ask what problem a SIF solves and whether they need that solution, rather than start with a generic allocation percentage.
I describe our launch as a tax-efficient income solution that fits an allocation containing debt or income, but not one consisting only of growth assets.
I see SIF’s appeal as MF tax efficiency, structure, and transparency combined with some additional alternative-like flexibility, and recommend comparing post-tax returns with PMS and AIF.
I regard derivatives as financial tools that can be useful when used sensibly by the right people; I cite arbitrage funds as an example of beneficial derivative use.
I said SIF does not allow leverage as a structure and that exposure is capped at 100%.
- When evaluating a SIF, I recommend asking for its time horizon, rolling returns over 1-2Y, rolling returns including the worst-case outcome in 1m and 3m, standard deviation, and open market exposure; these help indicate the experience an investor may have.
I say SIF requires a different capability from buy-and-hold investing and recommend asking the AMC about its capability.
I note that shorting can take different forms, including fundamental shorts, tactical shorts, and hedged derivative strategies.
I describe SIF as new and evolving, and advise investors to understand a product before investing and seek help from good advisors and MFDs where useful.
I said my team is happy to answer questions and that a webinar is coming soon; I gave no webinar date.
On 2025-09-30, I again shared thoughts on evaluating SIFs and said Altiva Hybrid Long Short, our first SIF, opens tomorrow.
On 2026-01-15, I introduced a nuanced take on how to evaluate hybrid SIFs, but the captured post does not include the evaluation criteria.
On 2026-01-15, I introduced a nuanced take on the Hybrid SIF category; the captured post gives no further detail about that take.
Related: sif investor education, other fund evaluation factors, sif launch and regulation