I distinguish the case for passive investing from predictions about which category or fund will outperform. Across these posts, I argue for choosing based on simplicity and underlying investment risk, not market narratives.
I have heard the narratives around large cap underperformance for years, but my view is that there is no clear trend.
I said there are years when active underperforms and years when it reverses, often depending on the kind of rally in indices.
I frame the case for passive funds as simplicity of choice and solution, rather than predicting which will outperform.
I reject the narratives “There is no alpha in MFs” and “Alpha will go away in the large cap space”; I say yearly data tells a different story.
My advice is: Don't forecast alpha or no alpha.
I say investors may buy passives if they want, because they represent a simple solution to investing, not because of narratives.
This view that passive investing can be a simple solution complements my broader discussion of passive fund innovation.
I said I had received multiple posts and messages like this: “I'm worried about markets so I have stopped my MF SIPs and switched to index funds.” This describes messages from others, not my own investment action.
I say index funds are not less risky simply because they are index funds.
In my comparison, buying an active small cap or small cap index fund carries the SAME risk - that of small caps.
I describe the only additional risk in an active fund as manager performance (could also be outperformance).
My advice to investors seeking safety is: choose hybrid or debt.
For the safety options I mention, see all weather hybrid funds. I do not specify particular funds, a time horizon, or a measure of risk.
Related: index fund choices, other fund evaluation factors, staying invested beats timing