I distinguish a fund manager’s total career experience from the time they have managed one scheme. I believe scheme tenure alone can mislead investors, particularly when comparing younger AMCs, and that continuity should be understood through institutional processes, oversight, and the kind of fund being managed.
I ask whether an investor should care more about 25 years of experience or 3 years managing the scheme when a CIO has 25 years of experience and has “managed my scheme for 3 years.”
I warn that “The analysis will look terribly biased for younger AMCs” that may have hired experienced fund managers but do not yet have schemes with long track records.
I ask, “What is the evidence that the same manager on a scheme is even better for the investor?” I am not arguing for annual turnover: “in 25 years, to have 2-3 managers is not bad.” If a scheme holds up well across multiple managers, “it speaks to the AMCs processes and lack of key man risk.”
I say short-term debt-fund and passive-fund managers “That has to be excluded from such analysis.” I add, “You don't want very experienced managers there, otherwise you get costs.”
I believe most AMC CIOs have “20+ years of experience managing markets, portfolios and liquidity over cycles.” I also say their CEOs are experienced.
I say, “Let's not use data to draw conclusions that scare people.” The industry manages a lot of money well for crores of investors, and markets already provide enough drama.
I agree that “I 💯 percent agree that churn that is excessive is bad,” while saying some churn is normal across industries. I describe an FM moving once in 5-7 years as reality in a competitive job market and compare that with CEOs of large global public companies changing every 5-7 years.
I say a scheme can be managed for 20 years by multiple people when appropriate processes, co-fund-manager models, and transitions are in place. I argue, “We are putting too much onus on individual FMs and not on the role an institution which is the AMC, its board and trustees play.”
I distinguish the NFO question from the question of young fund managers: “Your point on NFOs is different from young fund managers.” I support young talent, saying “young talent is led by experienced CIOs.”
Drawing on my 20 years of managing money, I say CIOs are deeply involved in process and risk management, including “oversight of all funds in their umbrella not just ones they are managers of.”
The quoted discussion of a discount factor for managers moving to a different AMC, long-term SIP horizons, and manager tenure in a scheme belongs to @ActusDei, not to me. Its point about NFO proliferation is truncated in the captured post.
I was “Very happy to read the last comment.” I said, “Process and principles driven AMC with a focus on consistency is what we want to stand for” at @EdelweissMF.
In a separate quoted post, @pallavagar described EdelweissMF equity funds as consistently performing over a long period and said their performance remained intact after a change in fund management. Those performance observations belong to @pallavagar; I expressed that I was happy to read the last comment.
Related: consistency and amc stability, active versus passive investing, other fund evaluation factors