I spoke as a shark during the Zen Barefoot pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 9. These notes distinguish my assessment and questions from founder Sahib Aggarwal’s, his father Sanjeev Kumar Aggarwal’s, and the other Sharks’ statements. I did not invest; I invited Sahib to return with a larger, more inspiring vision.
Sahib said he left his job to walk from Kanyakumari to Kashmir alone, while preparing for his first full marathon. He said he was injured wearing one of the best shoes and discovered barefoot shoes through an osteopath during physiotherapy. He described his father as a business pillar and CEO with “100% sweat, 0% equity.”
Sahib said a YouTube video about a music producer walking from the US west coast to the east coast inspired him to pursue something similarly crazy.
After leaving his job, Sahib freelanced to make money and pay rent; he saw a market gap and thought an MBA might cost more and teach him less over two years.
I asked why Sahib’s father had 0% equity: “And papa ki 0% equity kyun hai?”
Sahib’s rationale was: sports shoes are for sports; problems arise when people wear them or sneakers everywhere. He said cushioning is for loads beyond what feet can bear and cited sprinters as an example of athletes who do not use cushioned footwear.
Sahib said sprinters do not use cushioned footwear and described cushioning as useful when someone pushes beyond what their feet can bear.
Sahib said MyFootFunction in Sri Lanka compared feet of people who had never worn shoes with people who had. I described the theory I associate with Born to Run: the Tarahumara in South America run hundreds of kilometers at about 20 km per hour barefoot, and the theory links increased cushioning with injuries while arguing that running strengthens foot muscles.
Sahib’s customer-use estimate was 60 to 70% gym; 20ish% runners; 10% office or home. I challenged the designs as ugly, noting that runners also want good-looking shoes. Sahib said the website showed only the first model, while the shoes I was wearing were upcoming; when I said to cancel the launch, he replied that customers had requested the style, including an all-black option for office wear. I questioned why an athletic-shoe company was pursuing office-goer requirements.
Sanjeev’s cost and expense breakdown was cost 28%; freight and couriers 4%; Shopify and gateway charges about 4%; office expenses 30%; marketing 5%; R&D and travel 8%; total 79%; EBITDA 21%. I asked whether the website was selling with only 5% marketing.
Sahib described the airport-to-HSR walkers as 25 to 30 year olds; he wanted to make the lifestyle more fun and aspirational, not fancy. He said the market might grow 5 to 6X in at least five years and could reach 100, 150, or 200 crore. I noted the market was then in double-digit crores and asked whether it could reach 100 crore.
I assessed the hypothetical as a 50-60 crore company; 15-20 crore EBITDA in a 200-crore market; questioned investor return. I asked, “But then why are you raising money?” Sahib said the company was not limited to India.
I asked whether the ambition was an international barefoot brand rather than an athlete-first shoe brand in India.
Viraj said the logo reminded him of Adidas because of its three waves or stripes; he advised changing it and called the product “me-too.” He said he would invest if I invested and would be out if I was out.
I told Sahib, “Sahib, aap mujhe inspire nahi kar paaye.” I said I was probably his most targeted Shark because I had run 1,200 to 1,500 kilometers every year for the past 18 years, but I did not see the spark needed for an incredible athletic-shoe brand from India.
I declined to proceed with Viraj on this deal and invited Sahib to return with a larger, more inspiring vision. I said, “So for that reason right now, sorry Viraj, hum saath mein koi doosri deal karenge, but I think come back again with a larger, more inspiring vision.” I wished him well and said, “Just keep running.”
Open questions from the pitch included why Sahib’s father had no equity; whether Zen Barefoot was primarily athletic or also targeting office and lifestyle customers; whether the upcoming all-black shoe should launch; how the brand would address the design and logo concerns; how much marketing the website actually used; whether the stated market growth could support attractive investor returns; and whether Sahib would return with the larger vision I requested.