I spoke as a shark during the BabyWorks by Swapnil pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 32. These notes separate my questions and assessment from the founders’ and other Sharks’ statements. The reported business figures below are attributed to the speaker who gave them.
I stated the business’s ASP as 4,000: “4,000.”
Shrey Khandelwal said all sales were happening on Shopify: “Poora Shopify pe.”
I asked how the stated bottom line of 35% could be maintained: “Yeh aapka bottom line jo aapne bola tha, 35%, woh kaise hold kar pa rahe hain aap?”
Shrey Khandelwal said the marketing spend comparison was 29 to 30% last year; 25% in the current financial year. He said: “Jaisa humara last year jo economics tha, usme humara marketing spend jo tha, woh 29 to 30% tha. Is saal woh 25% pe aa chuka hai is financial year mein.”
Shrey Khandelwal reported that COGS was approximately 27% this year: “27% hai approximately.”
Shrey Khandelwal said last year’s COGS was 24%: “24.” I responded, “Okay, toh yehin se aaya sab.”
I asked whether customisation was the differentiation; no answer recorded. My question was: “Kya customisation aapka differentiation hai?”
Kunal Bahl offered 60 lakhs for 10%, saying he liked the founders and the business: “Achha Shrey, Swapnil, I like you, I like the business. 60 lakhs for 10%.”
Namita Thapar said the business was at about 1 crore; low barriers to entry; console or Labubu differentiator easy to copy. She said: “Swapnil, yeh ek aisa business hai at your scale, which is about 1 crore, jahan barriers to entry low hain. Jaise aap bol rahe ho na aapka differentiator hai ki ek console daal diya ya Labubu daal diya, it's very easy to copy. So for that reason, I am out.”
I was out for now because gross margin was an opportunity for smaller players and created scalability risk. I said: “Swapnil, Shrey, your gross margin is the opportunity for the smaller players. So that's why isme mujhe thodi scalability ki risk lagti hai. So which is why I am out for now, but great business. Best of luck.”
The excerpt does not state the currency for the 4,000 ASP, Kunal’s 60-lakh offer, or the scale reference of about 1 crore. It also does not explain exactly what the 35% bottom line measures, include an answer to my customisation question, or establish whether Kunal’s offer was accepted or a deal was ultimately made.
Swapnil Anuj Gupta said she had wanted to become an IFS officer and was now a CA, CS, and mother of two: “Toh actually mujhe IFS banna tha and it's a long story, but haan, for now main CA, CS aur do bachhon ki maa hoon.”
Swapnil Anuj Gupta confirmed that she and Shrey Khandelwal were siblings: “Ji.”