I spoke as a shark during the NAMO Vardan pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 50. These notes record my questions and assessment; the founders’ and other Sharks’ remarks are included as context, not as my words or views.
Lalji Pansuriya said he had 20 years of experience in live media as a reporter and anchor. I responded, “Are wah!”
I described NAMO Vardan as pre-revenue and asked how the founders knew the product was comfortable. I said cows are not accustomed to harnesses.
Abhishek Pansuriya said dung and cow urine would exit from below. I cautioned that if the kit was not changed periodically, cows could also get infections.
I asked how frequently the kit needed changing and what would happen if it was not changed and filled up. Abhishek answered, “paanch chhe baar hota hai.” I inferred that it would need changing “teen char baar.” The exchange does not clarify the time period or precisely what was counted.
I asked whether they sell the product or cow urine and cow dung. Aman Gupta responded, “Acha! Exactly sir.”
I asked about trademark risk. Kunal Bahl said the status was: application made; trademark not yet received.
I assessed NAMO Vardan as a product rather than a business; little time and money to make. I reasoned that if farmers liked it, lakhs of duplicate versions could emerge.
I praised the thought and effort behind NAMO Vardan but declined to invest; farmer interest could lead to lakhs of duplicate versions. I said, “Right now, I'm out.”
My evaluation covered cow comfort and harness familiarity, infection risk if the kit was not changed on time, change frequency, what happens when it fills up, what the product collects, trademark status, ease and cost of manufacture, and the likelihood of duplication. The exchange does not give manufacturing costs, price, sales, or other business figures. It leaves open whether “paanch chhe baar” refers to the kit filling five or six times, what the eventual change schedule should be, whether the trademark application later succeeded, and whether farmers adopted the product or duplicate versions emerged.
Lalji Pansuriya said the pitch had only just started: “Nahi nahi, yeh toh shuru hua hai sir abhi.”
Lalji Pansuriya said, “Yeh final hai sir.”
Aman Gupta said the cow looked uncomfortable: “Dekh ke hi uncomfortable lag raha hai bechari.”
Abhishek Pansuriya said the cow shed was dirty and that this increased infection chances: “Abhi ka aap situation dekho toh poore cow shed mein poora gandgi bhara mahol rehta hai, usme infections hone ke chances kaafi badh jaate hain.”
Abhishek Pansuriya said dung would exit from there and cow urine from below: “Haan sir, wahan se gobar nikal jayega, neeche se gaumutra nikal jayega.”
Aman Gupta responded, “Acha! Exactly sir.”