I spoke as a shark during the Chewie pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 24. These notes distinguish my questions and assessment from the founders’ statements and other Sharks’ comments. The excerpt ends with me going out; it does not record the founders’ ask, the other Sharks’ offers, or the final deal outcome.
The pitch was for Chewie on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 24.
The founders described Chewie as a food-waste-processing device. Mrudul Mudotholy said the three founders met at Mylen Foundry: he ran the industrial mobility solutions business as director, Jawahar led technology as CTO, and Dinesh headed manufacturing. Mrudul confirmed he was CEO.
Mrudul said Chewie’s MRP was 34,999.
The founders said the device needs electricity, a water inlet, and an outlet. It automatically flushes so that its interior is clean whenever the lid opens; bringing a plate or another item near it opens the lid. The founders said it photographs incoming waste, shreds it, mixes it with enzymes, selects what to inject and which parameters to control, and stores the output in the device, with no other user touchpoint. Mrudul said bones were included when Vineeta asked whether “meat” included bones. He called the output “regen soil,” ready for potting or disposable as dry waste once a month. He contrasted this bio-decomposition process with diaper disposal, which he said usually uses incineration.
When I asked why the device took a photo, Dinesh answered, “5 to 8 years.” The excerpt does not clarify what that answer referred to.
I asked what patent Chewie had received and whether it was an Indian patent; the excerpt contains no answer. Mrudul said everything was designed and made in India.
Mrudul initially said that at 1,000 units gross margin was around 40%, GM2 including indirect costs and SG&A was negative at -27%, and larger volumes would bring it to around 20% through amortisation.
Mrudul corrected the earlier figures, saying, “So number one, for 1,000 units, the negative EBIT applies, that is 40% is GM1 and minus 30% we get in terms of GM2.” The corrected unit economics at 1,000 units were GM1 40%; GM2 minus 30%; negative EBIT applies.
I challenged the margin explanation, asking how they could get to “-20” and what their SG&A was. I also asked the founders to give their current annual expenses; the excerpt records no answer. The initial and corrected margin accounts differ, and the transcript does not give the precise costs, SG&A, or volume assumptions behind them.
Dinesh said Chewie would improve its AI as installations scaled because wet-waste datasets were not available for all markets, and the company would expand when it was 100% sure they would not need a recall. The expansion recall-confidence threshold was 100% sure they would not need a recall.
I said 1 Crore households in India did not have an air purifier “aaj ki tareekh mein,” and described Chewie as “a good-to-have, this is not a washing machine, AC ki need hai.” My market and necessity assessment was good-to-have, not a washing machine or AC need; very tough task in India.
I said this was a very tough task in India, while the same number would be much easier in another market, and that making the product in India and selling it abroad would be “very patriotic.” I speculated that the founders might be avoiding the US because of lawsuit risk and assuming there would not be a lawsuit in India; that was my speculation, not a confirmed explanation from them.
I said the product did not look ready to me: “Because woh uske andar jab maine jhaank ke dekha toh kuch processing hui hi nahi thi. Even woh jo shredder hai woh khula nahi tha.” My product-readiness assessment was no processing seemed to have happened inside; shredder had not opened.
I said I felt the founders were not transparently communicating whether the product and manufacturing were ready, and questioned their confidence about launching outside India.
I declined the pitch, stating, “So for that reason, I'm out.” My stated reason was concern about product and manufacturing readiness.
I said staying alive was the most important task and warned that the company could shut down for lack of users, which would also prevent it from getting the dataset. My survival and dataset warning was company could shut down for lack of users, preventing it from getting the dataset.
Anupam Mittal joked that by the time the lid opened, Blinkit would have delivered and left. That was Anupam’s remark, not mine. The excerpt leaves unanswered what Dinesh meant by “5 to 8 years,” what Chewie’s Indian patent covered, the founders’ current annual expenses, whether the product and manufacturing were actually ready, and what the founders’ ask and eventual deal outcome were.
These are my remarks on the panel during the Chewie pitch, word for word, in the Hinglish I spoke on the show.
Dinesh Babu Sukumar said Chewie would scold someone who accidentally added plastic: “By mistake if you add plastic, Chewie will scold you.”
I praised the price as “not bad” and “seriously very good”: “Well done, not bad, good, very good, not bad, seriously very good.”
I reacted positively to the founders’ India-made design: “Amazing, very nice.”