I spoke on the PDD Falcon pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 29; PDD Falcon. The transcript distinguishes my [me] remarks from other speakers’ [other] remarks.
I understood the proposition as a steel-based Tupperware alternative; sustainable and eco-friendly. I said, “Toh isse aap sustainable bhi ho gaye aur eco-friendly bhi ho gaye, right?”
After Chirag described historical sales, I asked, “Aur is saal ka aapka projection kya hai?” The captured exchange does not include the current-year projection.
I asked whether the bottles had an exterior coating: “Toh isme kya aapne koi coating kiya hai oopar se?” Chirag replied that they used food-grade color.
I asked why all products were not branded; young consumers might hesitate about steel products. I also referred to Vineeta’s point that the brand was weak.
Sneha said each product involved minimum 13 se 15 processes. She described the steel polish as better than ordinary polish and said each product returned “ek nagine ki tarah.”
Sneha said almost 200 se 300 logon were involved in making each product, and described a roadmap for customers to associate “achha steel” with “Falcon steel.”
I raised a copying and patent concern: competitors could make nearly all products; nothing was patented to prevent copying. I said, “Isme kuch bhi aisa patented nahi hai ki woh copy nahi kar sakte.”
I was out because the category was non-cool, the brand needed a coolness factor, and the existing product mix would prevent the brand from forming. I said, “Jab tak yeh mix rahega na tab tak yeh brand nahi ban payega. Toh isiliye main bahar hoon.”
I described my son Ivaan as 1.5 saal old and said my wife used steel products when feeding him. I thought he might hesitate to use them in front of friends once he started school.
Chirag said sales before lockdown in “19-20” were 2.72 crores, and that the first year’s sales were 10 lakh.
Sneha said an Indian family uses an average 200 kgs of steel, which she called a standard norm. The captured exchange does not provide evidence or a source for that norm.
Chirag described the tiffin-and-related segment as a 5000 crore steel industry. I called the market very large; the exchange does not explain what the segment included or how its size was calculated.
Namita was also out, saying the other products did not stand out as particularly distinctive; that was her stated reasoning, not mine. I recognized that the market was large, but did not say its size changed my decision. The exchange leaves open what specific products, if any, were patented and what the current-year projection was.
Sneha said the founders’ roadmap was to establish the association “achha steel mane Falcon steel.”
Namita was out because she did not see anything particularly distinctive among the other products: “Baaki sab products mein kuch aise uth ke nahi aa raha hai ki kuch anokha hai aur us वजह se I'm out.”
Sneha said the stainless-steel sippers range could be large enough for one consumer to use three Falcon products: “Sirf ma'am stainless steel sippers ka range itna bada ban sakta hai ki ek hi consumer Falcon ke teen products use kar sakta hai.”