I questioned whether India’s ban on real-money gaming was a well-considered response to addiction and financial harm. I acknowledged those concerns while asking whether a total ban could instead cost public revenue and user protection, and benefit black markets. I did not endorse a definitive alternative policy; I ended by inviting others’ views.
I said the sector affected by India’s real-money gaming ban contributed ₹27,000 cr of GST annually, according to my post.
I said the sector drove ₹10,000 cr+ of ad revenue, according to my post.
I said the sector gave thousands a livelihood, without specifying a more exact count.
I acknowledged that many people got addicted and some went broke, while questioning whether those concerns justified a total ban.
I warned that a total ban could mean the government loses revenue, users lose protection, and black markets win.
I said that in the short term the ban felt like we’ve shot ourselves in the foot.
I suggested that in the long term the ban may allow real gaming & e-sports to emerge as one of the largest globally.
I hoped the ban was well thought out and not policing dressed up as policy, and asked readers for their take.
Related: real money gaming regulation, business policy and regulation, platform market harms and accountability