I have argued for business-policy changes that keep Indian companies viable and give founders room to build. These posts cover online real-money gaming taxation, company domicile rules, investor KYC paperwork, and tax and judicial overreach.
I estimated that online real-money gaming attracted $10 b bets every year and was growing at 50% a year.
I estimated that TOTAL wagering in India far exceeds $50b and will continue to grow regardless of naysayers talking about 80% shrinkage of the industry.
I identified the real questions as whether the shift to online will continue & how much will come under the tax net.
I distinguished offshore cos (offcos) that operate out of tax havens as one of three business types in the broader RMG space.
I described local guys (lcos) who pull in most of the moolah but dodge formal taxation as another business type.
I said online startup cos (startups) who will be most affected by the new tax regime are the third business type.
I described the tax as ~30% GST on all wagers as opposed to revenue and called the difference HUGE, citing 28% vs ~4% earlier.
I argued that offcos (& their beneficiaries :-)) and lcos are the biggest gainers of this change and will start to see growth again, much of which had stalled due to the rise of the startups.
I predicted that in the longer term it will lose out as the ‘legal’ market growth will stall and lcos & offcos do not come under the tax net.
I predicted Startups share will drop precipitously, with many of the smaller ones perishing and a few larger ones continuing to dominate after restructuring their business models.
I said the funding game in the sector is over and valuations will undoubtedly be bludgeoned.
I speculated that the government’s action was purely a short-term economic decision based on certain 'compulsions', while saying the narrative of 'protecting the vulnerable' was conspicuously absent.
My policy preference was to control & sustainably tax such businesses rather than make them unviable and push the informal economy ahead.
I hoped the government would move back to the earlier regime, helping transition offline, offshore and/or illegal activity toward a more transparent and tractable industry with adequate safeguards.
I urged policymakers to change ur rules requiring cos to flip their domicile outside of India, calling the requirement anachronistic, an unnecessary power-play, and a disservice to companies and founders given global macros.
I warned that reverse flips can be super-expensive & wasteful.
I said my team is spending inordinate amt of time sending kyc info to startups, which then coordinate with multiple angels to file paperwork with @IncomeTaxIndia instead of focusing on building businesses.
I said @IncomeTaxIndia already has all our PAN nos and many are registered investors.
I called the KYC paperwork its an unnecessary waste of time that sucks up countless unproductive hours of the country’s brightest.
I said we need policy making that keeps up with the country’s startup ambitions and asked the finance minister to look into the issue.
I said, Don’t know the full story behind fino payments CEO, Rishi Gupta’s arrest, while discussing the business environment.
I said overreach by tax authorities & judiciary are common and that I am also fighting baseless FIRs right up to Supreme Court.
I called for getting rid of onerous provisions and create an enabling environment if India is to produce world-beating companies.
Related: gaming regulation and policy, general tax and budget policy, real money gaming regulation