I spoke as a shark during the wellwith pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 44. I evaluated whether Sea Buckthorn had enough consumer demand and whether the product’s broad nutrition positioning matched what consumers were looking for. The founders’ ask and nutrition claims below are attributed to other speakers, not to me.
The wellwith founders asked for 1.5 Crores for 1.25% equity; Arun Solanki stated the ask.
I said companies had been marketing Sea Buckthorn juice for 18-20 years, but it had not become as popular as Orange Juice or Apple Juice, or as popular as Shilajit or Ashwagandha as a nutritional ingredient.
I asked how much of my daily RDA for Vitamin C and Omega 3 one shot would provide. A speaker answered “Around 20%”; another said Vitamin C provides 25% RDA, and I pointed out that 20 had just been said. The excerpt does not identify what nutrient “Around 20%” referred to or explain the discrepancy.
I said consumers look for a specific ingredient such as Shilajit, or for clear amounts of daily nutrients such as protein, calcium, Vitamin D, Vitamin C, and Omega 3; they were not looking for the founders’ broad, holistic Sea Buckthorn proposition.
I said Sea Buckthorn had neither a trend nor search volumes at that point.
I warned, “Trying to be everything for everyone is making it much harder for you to be anything for anyone.”
I declined to invest because I was not excited by the proposition: I saw no trend or search volumes for Sea Buckthorn and thought the broad positioning did not match consumers’ specific needs.
The founders described Sea Buckthorn as essential and wanted to increase the number of SKUs a family used, comparing it with toothpaste, oil, and flour. I evaluated the pitch by comparing the ingredient’s popularity with established juices and nutritional ingredients, and by asking about vegetarian status and the daily RDA supplied by one shot. The RDA answers were not reconciled in the excerpt. No investment terms or counteroffer from me are stated.
Nikhil Pratap Singh said Sea Buckthorn is found in some regions of Ladakh.
Nikhil Pratap Singh said Sea Buckthorn contains flavonoids, beta-carotene, carotenoids, and vitamin C.
A speaker told me, “please don't squeeze it.”
I said the product was “Bohot khatarnak tasting hai!”
I noted that Krill and fish oil were available in the same price range.
A speaker said Sea Buckthorn’s major purpose was to provide complete nutrition over time.
Nikhil Pratap Singh said Sea Buckthorn was essential for the body and should be taken in some form.
Nikhil Pratap Singh said the founders wanted to increase the number of SKUs used by a family, comparing them with toothpaste, oil, and flour.
I said the founders were attached to Sea Buckthorn’s holistic power.