I spoke as a shark during RidEV’s pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 10. These notes distinguish my questions and assessments from Siddharth Jain’s, Manish Kumar Jain’s, and the other panelists’ statements. I declined the original ask because I thought the vehicle payback implied an arbitrage and the rental yield was unsustainable. The transcript records a later counteroffer but does not establish whether a deal was finalized.
Siddharth said he had taken the CA exam 2-3 baar.
Manish said RidEV began in July '24 with around 10 vehicles and later operated more than 1400 vehicles in its fleet.
I said RidEV was the first EV company I had seen in five years to come to the show without its own EV, and asked whether it was only a platform and whether the vehicles belonged to the company.
Manish said 40 lakhs of his own money was in the business and RidEV had already raised 3 crore. I summarized that as 3.4 and asked how much was loan.
I asked about vehicle payback, using the example of a 1.2 lakh vehicle used for 365 days and recovering 1.2 lakh in 12 months: “Mujhe payback ka hi problem hai, actually. Aap bol rahe ho payback ek vehicle 1.2 lakh ka vehicle ka, agar koi poora 365 days use karta hai to 1.2 lakh nikal aata hai.”
Siddharth said, “Almost 1 lakh nikal jata hai easily.” I questioned why a rider would pay 1.2 lakh in a year for a 1.2 lakh vehicle.
I assessed RidEV’s pricing as an extraordinary arbitrage, called its rental yield unsustainable, and said I thought it would halve within a year.
Manish said B2C started in April and RidEV operated 750 vehicles in B2C in Hyderabad by October.
Manish said RidEV signed an agreement with Zomato covering 600 vehicles in Chennai; Zomato would purchase the vehicles and RidEV would operate them on a revenue-sharing model.
I asked what revenue share RidEV gave Zomato and whether it covered interest costs or something else; the transcript records no answer.
I declined the original 6 crore ask, saying I did not think it was worth that risk: “I don't think right now this is worth that risk, so for that reason I'm out.”
I explained subvention as a third party, such as a builder or company, paying part of someone’s loan to make the buying decision easier. My example was a builder paying EMIs until possession while the loan remained in the buyer’s name.
Manish’s counteroffer was 1 crore for 3% equity, and 5 crores debt for 14.5% IRR. I reacted, “Woo-hoo!”; the transcript does not establish that the deal was accepted or finalized.
My analysis probed whether RidEV owned its vehicles or was only a platform, fleet renewal, founder capital and borrowing, interest and other costs, contribution, net profit, vehicle payback, revenue sharing, and whether rental yields could persist. The transcript leaves unanswered the debt amount, customer renewal rate, contribution and net profit figures, exact vehicle-loan interest rate and its rationale, and the terms behind the original 6 crore ask. It also does not give the Zomato revenue-share percentage or establish whether the counteroffer became a deal.
Manish said RidEV bought vehicles at a good discount to market price.