I spoke as a shark during the Nootie pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 6. These notes distinguish my questions and assessments from the founders’ and other Sharks’ statements. The excerpt records no investment decision or offer from me, and several market-size and accounting questions remained unresolved.
I opened the pitch with “Nootie to every cutie!” and welcomed the founders to Season 5: “Welcome to Season 5.”
The founders described Nootie as a home-grown pet-care brand offering treats, food, grooming, and daily essentials for dogs and cats: “Nootie ek home-grown pet care brand hai jahan treats se leke food, grooming ke leke daily essentials, dogs aur cats ke liye sab kuch hi milta hai.”
I reacted to something in the discussion by saying, “Very nice, so thoughtful!” The excerpt does not make clear what prompted the reaction.
Akshay said Zepto invited Nootie to sell on the platform in 2022: “2022 ke andar hi humko Zepto se self-invitation aaya to sell on Zepto.”
Akshay said Nootie was listed on its website, “8-auto stores,” and every quick-commerce platform: “Aaj Nootie apni website, hamare 8-auto stores, aur har ek quick-commerce ke upar listed hai.” The transcript does not clarify what “8-auto stores” means.
Akshay said he had been trying for five years: “5 saal se try kar raha hoon sir.”
Akshay described the product as made of 100% human-grade material: “This is just to tell you that actually this is 100% human-grade material.”
I questioned charging ₹300 to commercialize a ready-to-eat meal that could be made at home with chicken, rice, and vegetables; I inferred that this explained Nootie selling it cheaply at 179: “Isliye aapne sasta becha, 179.”
Akshay said dogs were the biggest category: “No, dog is the biggest category.”
Anupam challenged the cat-market estimate by citing companies doing 500–800 crore and Whiskas at 1000 crore: “Lekin ek baat batao, 11 se 12% kaise hoga jab do teen company 500-800 crore kar rahi hai, for example Whiskas 1000 crore kar rahi hai”.
Akshay said 70–80% of Mars’s ₹2,200 crore portfolio was dog food: “Usme 80%, 70% dog food hi hai.”
I estimated Whiskas at 300–400 crore: “Toh Whiskas matlab 300-400 crore”.
I calculated 30% of ₹2,200 crore as about ₹700 crore and noted, “Unhone 700 se 1000 bola tha.”
Anupam said the calculation would make 600 crore and added, “Unhone utna hi bola tha.”
Akshay described Sheba as very premium and its market as very small: “Sheba is again very premium, very very small TAM”. I said the numbers from the two companies seemed different: “Somehow yaar inke numbers”.
Akshay said he was seeking investment to launch dry food: “Dry food ko launch karne ke liye aapke samne khada hoon sir.”
I said founders often do many things during their first 10–15 crore of growth to pay their bills, then challenged what they would choose to build when given the opportunity: “Aap jis dilemma se guzar rahe ho, Shark Tank pe kayi founders aate hain jo first 10-15 crore ki journey mein bahut cheezein karte hain kyunki unko apne bills pay karne padte hain.”
Akshay said Nootie itself had to become big: “Main aapko bata raha hoon Nootie hi bada hona hai, ultimately maine aapko kaha na”.
Akshay said commissions and discounting were included in the comparable economics: “Similar economics hai sir kyunki sir basically usme commissions bhi jaati hain, discounting bhi jaata hai”.
Akshay apologized and said he was overwhelmed: “I'm a little overwhelmed, sorry.” He later repeated that he was overwhelmed and might cry: “I'm genuinely very overwhelmed ma'am, I might cry right now, honestly.” I reassured him that he had done well: “Aapne bahut achha kiya.”
Asked what differed between two products both described as all-natural, Akshay said, “Kuch fark nahi hai.”
I praised Akshay’s answers as time ran out: “Toh aapne bahut achhi tareeke se questions answer kiye”.
The founders’ ask was ₹1 crore for 1.2% equity: “₹1 crore rupees for 1.2% equity.”
I asked the Delhi founders what they thought of the latest stray-dog policy: “Yeh latest jo policy hai of stray dogs, toh aapka uske baare mein kya sochne hai?”
I asked whether Akshay would eat the product, noting previous presenters had not: “aur aap yeh khane wale ho kya? Pichle walon ne khaya nahi!”
Akshay said Nootie had 2–3 SKUs for cats: “Yes ma'am, we have 2-3 SKUs for cats.”
Akshay estimated the packaged dog- and cat-food industry at ₹10,000–15,000 crore: “10 se 15,000 crore ki industry hai.”
Akshay’s cat-market share estimate was 11–12%: “Aaj industry ke andar 11 se 12% cat ka market hai, baaki rest abhi bhi dog ke saath hai.”
Akshay said Mars’s whole portfolio was ₹2,200 crore: “Sir ₹2,200 crore Mars ka poora portfolio hai.” The exchange did not resolve the differing market and Whiskas figures.
I described dry food as capital intensive and said it would require substantial manpower and fuel in the fire: “Dry food ek capital intensive market hai, it will require a lot of manpower and fuel in the fire.”
I challenged the shift between Nootie as the brand and a house-of-brands plan: “Abhi aap change kar rahe ho, abhi aapne Anupam ko bola house of brands my friend”.
I said wanting to get into customers’ homes was the problem: “Which is the problem!”
Akshay said Nootie was completely bootstrapped and had done about ₹18.5 crore in sales the previous year: “We are completely bootstrapped. Last year we did about 18.5 crores of sales.”
Akshay reported sales of ₹11.5 crore and ₹6.5 crore in the two preceding years: “₹11.5 crore tha, usse pehle saal ₹6.5 crore tha.”
Akshay said the channel split had been 50–50 through the previous year: “Last year tak 50-50 tha.”
Akshay said they had counted 6% as marketing and taken it below net revenue: “Humne 6% marketing mana hai.” “Hum usko net revenue ke neeche lete hain.” I objected that discounting should go above net revenue: “Woh net revenue ke upar jaana chahiye.”
Akshay confirmed ₹2.5 crore as net revenue: “₹2.5 crore aapka net revenue hai?” “Haan ji.”
I questioned the movement from 70% gross margin to 13%: “Aur yeh jo 70% gross margin se 13% ki journey hai usme kya aa raha hai?”
Akshay clarified that 70% was brand-level gross margin, not whole-company gross margin: “Ma'am 70 mera brand pe gross margin hai.” He said he was not giving the company’s gross margin: “Main aapko mere brand ka, mere company ka gross margin nahi bata raha hoon.”
Akshay said Smylo entered the category about a year earlier and only did cats: “They have just gotten into this category I think a year back. They are only doing cats.” Asked what differed between products both described as all-natural, he answered: “Kuch fark nahi hai.”
The founders described Nootie as a Delhi-based home-grown pet-care brand for dogs and cats. The exchange also covered Zepto and other distribution, product pricing, dry-food expansion, market sizing, channel mix, accounting, and comparison with Smylo. Their stray-dog policy response is not captured, and the phrase “8-auto stores” in the distribution claim is unclear. The market-size disagreement and the margin-accounting explanation remain unresolved; the excerpt ends without an offer or investment decision.