I spoke as a shark during the Every Morning Cartel pitch in Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 12. These notes distinguish my remarks from the founders’ and other Sharks’ statements; the transcript does not record the founders’ final decision or the outcome of the offers.
The founders were Neel and Rishi from Mumbai; ₹2 Crore for 5% equity was their ask.
I praised the watermelon and gnocchi textures. I said, “Tarbooz matlab koi believe nahi karega tarbooz hai,” and called the gnocchi texture phenomenal.
I called the brand flawed-some and said we are awesome with our flaws.
Neel said the venue had 55 seats. I asked about the food-versus-beverage split, but the transcript gives no answer.
I considered Tier 2 places in metros a good idea after Neel described customers in Tier 2 suburbs of Tier 1 cities as having the taste and money for luxury F&B and world-class coffee.
I declined because I did not understand how the business would scale and feared scaling could compromise the heart and soul of its food and coffee.
I identified real estate and chefs as scaling problems and reiterated that I was out; I also praised the founders.
Ritesh Agarwal offered ₹2 Crore for 10%. I observed that this matched the founders’ ask in amount but differed in equity.
Aman Gupta and Ritesh Agarwal’s joint offer was ₹2 Crores total, ₹1-1 Crore each, 7-7% each, 14% total.
Reacting to the joint offer, I exclaimed Anarth ho gaya, anarth ho gaya.
The transcript does not say whether the founders accepted either offer, negotiated, or left without a deal. It also does not explain how they would scale the food, coffee, chef capability, and real-estate footprint while preserving the experience, or identify the specific cities and locations they would choose.
I described the pitch meal as a 5 course meal.
Neel said his father had been running a small cafe for the past 10 years.
Neel described the brand as “chaos branding” and said it was breaking all the rules.
Neel said the watermelon had been slow cooked, served cold, and paired with Ponzu sauce.
Rishiraj said the dessert was made with 70% Belgium dark chocolate, single origin, with olive oil and salt on top.
Aman Gupta said fine-dine restaurants cannot be impatient.