I proposed that anyone with revenue above 100mill$ or raised over 250mill should fall in this category; the post did not specify what the category was.
I expected the move to “Will improve the credibility of Start-Ups and not let a few rotten apples set Destination and Shining India back in reputation”.
In response to a quoted report about BYJU’S shareholders calling for an extraordinary general meeting, I hoped they would see the effort through: “Hope its not a whiff and then whimper but they will stay the course and get this done”. The report was @ranjanir_’s, not my own announcement.
I said completing the effort mattered “For india as an investment destination ! For just credibility overall of an otherwise sunrise and sunshine sector”.
I have questioned the circumstances around Byju’s board resignations without verifying the claims quoted in the post. I framed my question about India and Dubai as curiosity, explicitly saying I was not pointing fingers.
I asked, “Is there an extradition treaty between India and Dubai ?” and said I was “Just curious” and “just asking,” with “no finger pointing.”
I remarked that company representatives were “last spotted” speaking with an Indian flag in the backdrop while being from “‘global’ locations”; I did not identify the representatives or locations.
I called Harsh’s tweet summary “sharp.”
I wrote, “Isme Bahut Log ka dimag fail ho gaya hai 😂😂,” and added, “Abhi Tak To Picture Baki hai.”
I did not explain what “this” referred to. In the quoted exchange, Harsh (@hvgoenka) addressed me; his statements about speaking from hearsay and asking what was right or wrong were his, not mine.
I said, “Couldn’t agree more @amitabhk87 -” and argued that “Most investors don’t ask hard Qs to founders & toe the middle line-only to be shocked!”
I asked whether an entity that “raised more than 400cr or revenue > 400cr” should, like a listed company, “have 2 independent Directors and a CFO at all times ?” This was a question, not a report that such a rule had been adopted.
I raised the governance question because I think investors often avoid hard questions for founders and are later shocked. The post gives no policy outcome or implementation details. The quoted article’s view that startup self-governance is non-negotiable belongs to @amitabhk87, not me.
I said, “Just broadly speaking in most cases the Qs are clear,” then named the Satyam, Theranos, and WeWork endings and wrote, “don’t really see a 4th option.”
I described two possible founder paths: “Founder is OUT as soon as and company can get salvaged” or the founder “does not ACCEPT and drags company/team and everyone down.” I presented these as alternatives, not as an outcome at a named company.
I argued that “early investors CANNOT be exonerated” if they sat on boards and gave approval “for years of delusional fund raising and valuation” before pleading ignorance and inability.
I called that conduct “Unacceptable ( founders beware)” and said, “even today Investors can ACT and take hard calls available to them” to redeem past culpability or “remain accountable for in-action.”
I clarified, “I repeat - above 👆 Just broad comments - just personal views - nothing specific to any company.”
I judge startup culture and governance by whether founders and companies honor long-term commitments to employees, shareholders, and the wider investment ecosystem.
I love the Indian startup world but worry that daily ESOP vesting kills the reason ESOPs are awarded.
I likened daily ESOP vesting to a company saying “don’t stay to buy into my vision-let me bribe U- I am raising more investor money than I know what to do with”.
I contrasted the founder-to-shareholder statements this way: 2005 offered to top up shares while building a Co for the next decade; 2022 said to pay 4,444Cr to get out.
I asked, “Which one is building a Co: to OUTLAST all?”
I called the BYJU’S drama “ZERO Content” and said it was sullying India’s name as a great investment destination.
I asked, “Wonder what it’s erstwhile Board thinks of their fiduciary duties”.
I criticized a “daily tirade of delusional PR,” urged people to “smell the coffee,” and asked “no Qs to their Board?”
I clarified that these were “my personal views-not @upGrad_edu”.
Related: edtech hype and credibility, venture capital critiques, education system and policy