I spoke as a shark during ExperientialEtc.’s pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 32. The transcript distinguishes my words, marked [me], from other speakers’ words, marked [other]; their remarks provide context and are not my words or views.
I asked whether the company had first brought its PVR-related offering to India, and Karan said it had: “Ye maine PVR mein dekha hai, toh sabse pehle aap laaye the India mein?”
I asked who was number one in the field. Karan answered that the company was number one by content and by the number of brands served: “Toh is field mein number one kaun hai India mein?”
I was impressed by the offering and its own hologram and glasses models: “Achi baat hai, isse main impress hoon.”
I had not used the service and had not been pitched to despite the marketing team being active in the market: “But aaj tak maine aapki service use nahi ki, hamari toh marketing team ghoom rahi hai market mein, aaj tak aapne hame pitch nahi kiya?”
Karan reported first year ₹18 lakh revenue and around 9.5% EBITDA; second year ₹86 lakh revenue and around 8.5% EBITDA; third year around ₹90 lakh revenue and 7.5% EBITDA; profitable from the first month: “Ab hamara pehla hi mahine se hum profitable rahe hain, 18 lakh rupe ki hamari revenue thi aur humne pehle hi saal mein around 9.5% ka EBITDA hit kiya tha.”
Karan reported second-year revenue of 86 lakh rupe and EBITDA around 8.5%: “Second year mein we did 86 lakh rupe aur hamara EBITDA around 8.5% raha.”
Karan reported third-year revenue of around 90 lakh rupe and EBITDA of 7.5%: “Third year mein we did around 90 lakh rupe aur hamara EBITDA 7.5% raha.”
I explained EBITDA as net earnings after expenses excluding interest, tax, depreciation, and amortization: “EBITDA jo hota hai business ka net income hota hai saare kharche daalne ke baad, marketing aur jo bhi kharche hain, toh net income except char key components: interest, tax, depreciation aur amortization.”
Karan said the company had done close to a crore after 6-8 months had passed in the stated 2021 aur 22 period: “2021 aur 22, jo abhi 6-8 mahine gaye hain, is period mein humne already close to a crore kar liya hai business.”
I challenged why Xiaomi would stay if another provider offered the same service more cheaply: “Xiaomi aapne bola ki aapka retainer client hai, kal ko agar main jaake Xiaomi ko yehi service saste daam mein deta hoon, toh woh mere saath aa jayega, aapke saath kyun rahega?”
Karan argued that a cheaper price would not match the company’s creativity: “Because aap daam sasta laga lenge, par jo creativity hai woh nahi kar payenge.”
Xiaomi generated around ₹50 lakh in six months; I characterized Xiaomi as 50% of revenue for the year and said revenue would be halved if Xiaomi left: “Tōh 50% revenue aapka Xiaomi se hai is saal mein. Ek client pe bahut dependency hai, nahi?”
Namita’s concern was 150 brands served but 50% of revenue from one company, with insufficient repeat-customer visibility: “Mujhe woh khatak raha hai ki aapke 150 brands kar chuke hain lekin 50% revenue sirph ek company se aa raha hai, toh woh jo repeat customers jo bahut important hote hain ek service business ke liye, woh visibility mujhe nahi aa rahi hai, toh us reason se I am out.”
Karan stated around ₹1,500 fixed cost and around ₹6.5–7 lakh sale price for the demonstrated service: “Meri costing isme hogi around, fixed cost hi hogi, usme around 1500 rupe aur bechunga around main 6.5-7 lakh rupe mein.”
I raised a ₹30,000-₹40,000 salary comparison in an incomplete sentence: “30,000-40,000 is the salary that”
I called the founders’ ideas phenomenal and predicted they would get orders whether or not they got a deal: “Ye cheez toh kahunga ki jo aapke ideas hain na, woh phenomenal hain. Yahan se jaane ke baad aapko deal mile na mile, aapko order zaroor mil jayenge.”
I assessed that the business was doing everything, had no USP yet, and had no margin, with 8-9% EBITDA: “Abhi aap sab kuch kar rahe hain aur is business mein abhi koi USP nahi hai, margin hai nahi business.”
I saw value in making the business scalable through engineering hires and technology-based sales, so customers could purchase online automatically rather than relying on Karan to sell: “Main offer de sakta hoon kyunki itna high risk hai abhi isme aur pata nahi ki aage kya hoga.”
I offered ₹2 crore for at least one-third of the company, framing it as high risk and tying my value-add to making the business scalable: “Main offer de sakta hoon kyunki itna high risk hai abhi isme aur pata nahi ki aage kya hoga.”
Karan counteroffered 8%; then 10% equity and 2% advisory shares: “and I am willing to offer 8%.”
I declined to continue negotiating and left without a deal; I said I would become a customer and that the issue was the business stage, not the pitch: “Dekho main aapka customer banunga. Aaj unfortunately mujhe bahar jana padega.”