This was Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 17. Pitch: Outbox.
I spoke as a shark during Outbox’s pitch. The transcript describes my words as word for word, in the Hinglish I spoke on the show. Remarks marked [other] were spoken by other people and are included for context, not as my words or views.
I reacted to Sukriti Agarwal describing the service as “For a couple” with, “For a couple, wow!”
Kaushal Modi said Outbox had generated 5 CR in gross sales: “Abhi tak hum log ne 5 CR ka revenue generate kiya hai gross sales.”
I separately described it as a 1 crore business and said it was “not small”: “I think size se main bada surprise hoon, 1 crore ka business is not small.” The transcript does not explain the difference between this figure and Kaushal’s 5 CR gross-sales figure.
Kaushal explained that customers could select standard services or add-ons, choose a date and time, raise a query through Check availability, or complete an online booking through order now. He said, “Toh yeh jaise variants hain, toh variants mein jaise agar aapko standard service lene hain ya add-ons wale lene hain usme aap kuch bhi select kar sakte hain, date and time aap select kar sakte hain. Check availability aapko khaali query raise karne ke liye hai aur order now matlab aap complete booking aap online bhi kar sakte hain.”
Ashneer Grover called it a showbaazi business dependent on visual appeal and experience; criticized its logo and website. He said, “Aapka jo business hai, woh event ho gaya toh showbaazi ka business hai,” and criticized the website as well.
I assessed Outbox as not defensible; could be copied and scaled by someone with tech co-founders. I said, “Par jo business hai na woh defensible nahi hai, yeh copy kar sakta hai koi bhi jiske paas bhi tech co-founders vagaira hain yeh scale kara jaa sakta hai.”
I said personalized surprises are preferable, but employees have to carry them out: “Matlab mujhe bhi usually kisi na kisi ko surprise karna hota hai aur woh personalised ho toh better rehta hai, but aakhe time toh employees ko hi karna hota hai.”
I declined because Outbox needed a good tech co-founder, not a tech shark: “But na yeh aapka experience dekh ke clear hai ki aapko ek badhiya tech co-founder ki zaroorat hai, tech Shark ki zaroorat nahi hai mujhe aisa lag raha hai. So aaj ke liye, I am out.” My broader concern was that the business was not defensible and could be copied and scaled by someone with tech co-founders.
I called Sukriti a very enterprising entrepreneur and said I was on Sukriti's side: “Aur yeh toh bohot hi enterprising entrepreneur hain” and “Main bilkul Sukriti ke saath hoon.” I rejected Anupam Mittal’s suggestion that the founders should be acqui-hired.
Anupam could not invest that day; he wanted to continue the conversation after the pitch and said the founders needed to work harder first: “Look, aaj ke liye main nahi invest kar paunga. Lekin main yeh conversation zaari rakhna chahta hoon. Yahan se bahar jaayenge toh baat karenge. Thoda aapko mehnat aur karni padegi, lekin uske baad shayad kuch kar sakte hain.”
I urged the founders to launch in Delhi and Bombay so they could surprise the sharks: “Aap ye please Delhi mein bhi launch karein aur Bombay mein, taaki aap apne Sharks ko surprise kar paayein!”
Ashneer Grover said he was lost on the business and was out: “Toh main wahan pe hi lost ho gaya hoon ispe. Isliye main at least isse bahar hoon.”
I joked that I would pitch to the sharks one by one and make offers they could not refuse: “Main chala jaaunga pitch karne fir ek ek offer bana ke de dunga, aap mana nahi kar paoge!”