I remember my Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 34 exchange during the Saras pitch. I distinguish my assessment and decision from founder Sarthak Joshi’s account and Anupam Mittal’s separate regulatory concern; their statements provide context, not my views.
My Saras pitch exchange was on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 34.
Sarthak Joshi said the founders were from Surat and were Saras’s founders: “Hum Surat se hain Saras ke founders.”
I opened the exchange with “Bahut Saras!”
I asked the founders, “So what is your monetisation strategy?” The captured exchange does not include their answer.
Sarthak said the founders considered multiple revenue options and chose not to use subscriptions: “we would not want to go the subscription way.”
Sarthak said their research suggested the subscription market could grow only up to a limit: “wo ek limit tak hi grow ho pa raha hai.”
Sarthak reported Saras’s MAU as around 11,846: “MAU is around 11,846”.
Sarthak reported Saras’s DAU as 2,045: “DAU is 2,045.”
I called the engagement figures “Very low” and “bohot kam hai na.”
Anupam Mittal questioned whether turning an advisory platform into a brokerage was legal in spirit, said he was unsure, and passed: “I am not sure.” and “So I'm out, good luck guys.”
I said a good idea should cut through the noise and attract enough downloads, MAU, and DAU for people to want it: “if the idea is good, it cuts through butter like a hot knife.”
I cited Saras’s 50,000 downloads: “aapke hain 50,000 downloads”.
I also cited 11,846 MAU and 2,045 DAU, which I called “very tiny.”
I said Saras’s business model was not robust and declined to invest for today: “business model hi robust nahi hai, Saras nahi hai” and “I'm out for today.”
I asked about monetisation, but this excerpt does not record the founders’ answer beyond their decision against subscriptions. Anupam’s concern about the advisory-to-brokerage model’s legality is unresolved in the exchange. I advised the founders to work on the business model; the excerpt does not say what changed afterward.