I remember my Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 10 exchange during RidEV’s pitch. I distinguish my questions, views, and exit from the founders’ and other Sharks’ statements, which provide context rather than representing my words or views.
I called the proposed 3% equity deal “Very reasonable.”
I questioned whether a 3,000 security deposit was meaningful, saying, “Woh to kuch nahi hai na.” The transcript does not specify the deposit’s currency.
I asked what happened to the 40% who did not renew and whether returned scooters were in good condition: “40% jo renew nahi karte woh kya karte hain?” and “Return karke in good condition?” Siddharth Jain said customers returned the scooters and left; the transcript records no answer about their condition.
Siddharth Jain said, “60%.”
After hearing the non-renewal figure, I said, “Oh, that's high.”
I asked where the business captured value and what costs remained; after Siddharth asked what costs lay below revenue, I said, “Uske baad interest aur depreciation hi hai bas.”
When Vineeta Singh argued that pricing arbitrage made the rental yield unsustainable and predicted it would halve within a year, I asked, “To aap bataiye barrier to entry kya hai?”
I challenged the claimed charging-network moat, asking whether RidEV was really building a network and comparing the claim with Elon Musk’s Supercharger network: “Aap abhi network bhi build kar rahe hain?” and “To Elon Musk ke supercharger network ban gaye ho, yaar?”
Manish Kumar Jain said RidEV had 80 charging stations for 1400 vehicles. I asked, “For 1400 vehicles?” and “Aur uska kharcha kahan se nikal raha hai?”
I questioned whether competitors could install charging stations too: “Woh bhi to koi kar sakta hai na?” Manish said RidEV charged riders for charging; he described locating space, installing chargers, and preparing stations as part of the work.
Manish Kumar Jain said RidEV’s charging stations were applicable only to its own vehicles: “Hum fast charger purchase karte hain aur usko multiple location mein install karwate hain jo sirf humari gaadiyon ke liye hi applicable hai, sirf wahi jake charge kar sakte hain.”
Manish Kumar Jain said RidEV collected payment from riders for charging: “Hum charger se rider se charge karte hain charging ka, jo bhi woh charge karega, hum usse woh payment lete hain charging ka.”
I said technology was not a barrier to entry and asked Manish for a third reason: “Tech to koi bhi bana sakta hai, yaar. Aajkal to tech is not a barrier to entry. Woh mat batayein, teesra batayein.”
I challenged the durability of gig-worker marketing as an advantage, saying, “Marketing agar itna kiya hai aur agar woh aapka USP hai to 1 year is a long time,” and pointing to quick-commerce growth, multiple players, and RidEV’s 1400 vehicles.
Manish Kumar Jain described gig-worker marketing as a network advantage and gave a hypothetical involving 100 new vehicles: “Third thing hai jo humne marketing ki hai saare gig workers ke saath mein jake, aaj ki date mein humara network aisa hai ki aaj humare paas agar 100 new vehicles aa rahi hai to entire gig worker”
Manish Kumar Jain said a vehicle would become old after 2 years: “aaj meri gaadi 2 saal chal gayi hai aur woh 2 saal baad purani ho jayegi”.
Manish Kumar Jain said charging infrastructure was needed to retain riders: “Usko intact rakhne ke liye mujhe charging infra chahiye.”
Varun Alagh said the current situation did not show what the business might become in 3 years and predicted 3-3, 4-4 competitors could open in every city: “3 saal baad kya banne wala hai. In fact, har shehar mein jo hai, 3-3, 4-4 competition aapke khul jayenge.”
Kunal Bahl described the business as operationally rigorous and hard to execute, and said execution created a barrier to entry: “Yeh ek finance kum operationally rigorous business hai, isliye bahut hard hai. Aur mujhe lagta hai isiliye ismein barrier to entry actually hai.”
Kunal Bahl characterized the business as an execution game: “Woh execution game hai.”
I exited the discussion, saying, “Bye bye bye, I am out.”
After Varun Alagh said barriers to entry were low, I emphasized, “Zero hai zero.”
Vineeta Singh said recovering the full cost of a 1.2 lakh asset in 12 months implied arbitrage and that she did not consider the risk justified for a 6 crore ask; I called it risky: “Its risky.”
I challenged Kunal Bahl’s description of the business as not capital-intensive, asking, “Yeh woh capital intensive nahi hota hai?” and saying, “Aap misguide kar rahe ho unko.” Kunal replied, “Absolutely capital intensive hota hai, maybe aapko pata nahi hai.”
I clarified that I cited Musk as a scaling-risk caution: “Musk maine isliye quote kiya, just so you're aware,” and said the U.S. Supercharger network needed 500 million dollars to scale. I urged the founders to study the risks and benefits of moving from 80 charging stations in Hyderabad to pan-India coverage.
Kunal Bahl said no to the offer under discussion but that his deal stood if the founders wanted it. I asked, “Completely fixed, yeah?” The transcript does not record the founders’ answer or the final deal outcome.