I use other people’s investment preferences as a reminder to keep my own portfolio personal: Your uncle buys smallcaps; your friend loves crypto; your neighbor can't think beyond FD. My advice is, “Should be about you, not them.”
I summed up that advice with: Suno sabki, portfolio apni.
I described this as “A series of Mango Money problems and small answers by Niranjan Avasthi” and invited readers: “Let's create more Mango Millionaires.” I also asked readers to keep sending book feedback.
I have seen more friends, family, and others ask me for portfolio advice in recent months, against a backdrop of high volatility across asset classes, returns over the last year have been muted to negative for some, and noise and confusion prevails.
I said that neither me, nor anyone else, can give you a quick fix for a portfolio, because “Investment advice requires time and context.”
I cautioned that “Too many people want to buy funds, before learning basic finance.” I described that as “Diving before learning how to breathe.”
I suggested Mango Millionaire as a starting place, calling it “our book Mango Millionaire is a good one.” This connects my personal-planning guidance to investment fundamentals.
I recommend making a personal investment statement to document your money situation and needs. I said to “Cover four things”; the four areas are income and expenses, current investments and liabilities, goals and timelines, and thoughts on risk, including losing money.
I advised taking the personal investment statement to a personal-finance professional: “Please go talk to a good personal finance professional - either MFD or investment advisor.” I said people could talk to multiple folks and then find someone they are comfortable with.
I advised, “Do not rush to make a financial monument.” I said, “You don't need to have a direct stock portfolio, figure out whether to buy silver or find a PMS.” Those decisions can wait until you find your feet.
My advice is to start if you have not started investing; if you have made mistakes, relax. I said, “Everyone does.” I cited the financial crisis of 2008 as an example of very smart people making mistakes, and wrote: “Relax, reflect and learn.”
I compared market corrections to board exams: “Painful, but extraordinary teachers.” My advice was, “Pay the tuition fee, and move forward.”
The 30,000 investment question—whether to buy silver and which fund to choose—does not receive a product recommendation. I emphasize preparation, personal circumstances, and professional guidance instead; the post does not specify the currency or recommend an allocation, fund, silver purchase, direct-stock portfolio, or PMS. This process-oriented approach complements the personal-suitability ideas in personal finance reflections.
I relayed the investment question, “I have 30,000 to invest, should I buy silver?” and “What fund do I buy?” The example does not specify a currency.
I urged people to educate themselves on the basics before making investment choices: “Please educate yourself on the basics.”
I said the personal investment statement should cover “your thoughts on risk - losing money.” Together with income and expenses, current investments and liabilities, and goals and timelines, this is the fourth of the four areas I listed.
I said to “Talk to multiple folks if you want” and then “find someone you are comfortable with” when seeking professional financial advice.
I cited the financial crisis of 2008, saying it “was caused by some very smart people making mistakes.” I reassured readers, “You are allowed a few too.”
I think personal finance should reflect the circumstances of the person making the decisions. My own investment history, household exposure to markets, and crisis guidance have shaped how I think about managing money.
I urged people to manage their money “like a Pro,” but did not explain what that means or identify the “one more reason.”
I described a Business Standard item as capturing “a very heartfelt tweet” using #advicezaroorihai; the post did not give the tweet’s text or author.
I started earning in 2005 and investing in 2006/2007. Young, excited, working on Wall Street, and assuming I was smarter than I was, I invested entirely in equities.
My husband and I worked in the same profession. In 2008, the market fell, firms’ AUMs fell, bonuses collapsed, and so did ESOPs; the effects applied to both of us.
After the 2008 downturn, I decided to move to India in 2009 to start a business and withdrew capital at significant cuts. I said the story was on YouTube, without providing a link or further details.
My current investments are largely in BAF (70 percent), with the balance in equities, including mid- and small-cap equities. I described BAF as balanced advantage funds, a blend of equity and debt.
I said we have no debt because we pay EMIs, so debt does not make sense for us.
I keep my investments somewhat conservative because my husband and I are both capital-markets professionals; together, our household is “essentially a high beta bet on markets.” I said 2008 taught me this lesson and that 2020 felt much easier.
I said my answer and portfolio would look different if my husband were a doctor or worked in another uncorrelated field. My takeaway was that investments should be a function of personal circumstances: “personal” comes first in “personal finance.”
- For a crisis, I recommended five priorities: keep high liquidity; watch expenses; focus on survival rather than growth; better yourself instead of worrying about the environment; and be optimistic. I concluded, “the strong will get stronger.”
This crisis guidance applies business advice to personal finance, but the post does not specify which crisis or what “the environment” means. My broader investing foundations include investment fundamentals, and my description of balanced advantage funds connects to all weather hybrid funds.
I framed the money-management post as “One more reason,” but did not say what the reason was.
Related: building diversified portfolios, investment fundamentals, personal finance reflections