I distinguish investments from purchases that also serve emotional or personal needs. When I assess a primary home, I compare its personal-use value with the rental-yield math rather than assuming that every valuable asset is an investment.
I note that buying a home often does not make sense on rental-yield math alone: “If investing was logical, very few of us would buy a home because the rental yield math never justifies it!”
I recognize that homes can carry emotional and personal-use value: “Emotional value is hard to argue with and finally you can’t live in an NAV and do up a folio to your liking.”
I believe primary homes with this personal component should not be treated as investments: “The important thing however is to accept that primary homes have this component and not treat them as investments.”
I see the same personal component in jewellery and, in some cases, angel investing: “The same is true for many of us with jewellery. In some cases angel investing as well.”
I reserve the term investments for assets I can assess with a truly unemotional lens: “Investments are those that you can treat with a truly unemotional lens.”
I have described housing and property markets through both personal experience and public discussion: a striking US loan approval, questions about real-estate prices and REITs, and difficult experiences as a homebuyer in India.
In 2004, when I was 20, I received a call from an office in Miami saying I was being approved for a $0.5 million dollar housing loan in the US.
At the time, I had no income, no job, and no assets, and I also had a small student loan.
Then and now, that call reminds me that markets are irrational.
I promoted a real-estate discussion asking, “Where do home prices go?” and “What does WFH to do commercial property?”
I also asked whether REITs are a good idea and shared a link to the discussion: bit.ly/37YlnKN.
I called real estate “the single most dangerous asset class in India,” reflecting on what I had gone through despite RERA and being in capital markets.
After my experience, I said I would never buy a real estate project again.
I thanked Vishal and Moneycontrol for telling my story and the story of many homebuyers in the country.
I described buying a home as a dream involving a lot of hard-earned money, and said, “It shouldn’t be like this.”
I said honest communication from builders would really help, and shared the lesson I took from the 2008 market crisis: when times are bad, talk more.
Related: saving and joyful spending, learning from experience, talent over investing