I have argued that access to frequent investment data can shorten my time horizon and make ordinary volatility more noticeable. I recommend evaluating investments over the horizon for which they were designed, and have shared figures attributed to Edelweiss MF internal analysis that show a lower reported chance of seeing red at less frequent NAV-checking intervals.
Data helps us make better decisions. But it can also shorten our time horizon.
I contrasted patient holdings—FDs, single malts, private businesses, even ancestral furniture—with stocks and mutual funds that can be checked anytime.
I wrote, “Here's the irony: volatility rises the more often you look.” I said the investment itself has not changed; only the frequency of observation has.
I suggested evaluating investments over the horizon they were designed for: An overnight fund can be judged daily. An equity fund probably can't.
In my house-with-a-live-NAV thought experiment, It wouldn't become more volatile. You'd just notice the volatility more.
I imagined that you'd check it ten times a day, compare it with your neighbour's, obsess over whether you paid the right price, and have the occasional anxiety attack.
I asked, “How often do you check your NAV?” and reported that Daily: 46% chance you see red.
I reported that Monthly: 39% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
I reported that Yearly: 23% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
I reported that Every 3 years: 6% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
I reported that Every 5 years: 0% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
I concluded, “In this case, Kumbhkaran was the wise one.” I attributed the reported figures to internal analysis at Edelweiss MF.
In a separate post, I again asked, “How often do you check your NAV?” and reported that Daily: 46% chance you see red.
In that post, I reported that Monthly: 39% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
In that post, I reported that Yearly: 23% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
In that post, I reported that Every 3 years: 6% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
In that post, I reported that Every 5 years: 0% chance of seeing red when checking NAV.
I again concluded, “In this case, Kumbhkaran was the wise one,” and attributed the figures to @EdelweissMF internal analysis.
Related: emotions and portfolio monitoring, staying invested beats timing, reviewing personal portfolios