I spoke as a shark during PNT Robotics and Automation Solutions’ pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 15. This page records my comments and assessments; Pratik Tirodkar’s remarks are included only as context and are not my words or views.
Pratik Tirodkar said the team had made two small prototypes for COVID and then made a third prototype after continued discussions with doctors and gathering their inputs.
Pratik said the robot was intended to deliver food in a COVID ward and take patients’ used clothes outside.
I asked whether the founders were now doing this full time; the excerpt records no substantive answer to my question.
I asked whether the intended end use was to build a project-type robot or to enter robotics more broadly; the excerpt records no answer to that question.
I said the founder had turned a college project into his life: “Yaar tum na college project ko zindagi bana di tumne.”
I called the device a toy rather than a robot and said it could not be useful to anyone: “Ye robot nahi hai, ye khilona hai.”
I contrasted my view of the device with 1980, saying people then would have considered it a robot, whereas no sensible person would call it one today: “aaj ki date mein koi bhi samajhdar banda isko robot nahi maanta.”
I advised the founder that, if he could code and do hardware, he should work at a good company and first understand the problem before trying to solve it: “kisi achhi company mein kaam karo”.
I called the project entertainment and nothing more: “Entertainment hai ye, aur kuch nahi hai.”
I was out of the pitch: “Main isse bahar hoon.” My stated rationale was that I considered the device a toy rather than a useful robot and saw the project as entertainment.
The excerpt gives no technical specifications, testing methodology, performance measurements, business figures, investment terms, or final pitch outcome beyond my saying I was out.
My PNT Robotics panel remarks were word-for-word in the Hinglish I spoke on the show.
I said I understood that the founders had done many things: “Humein samajh aa gaya tumne boht sari cheezein kari hain”.
I called the founder very smart: “Tum boht smart bande ho”.