I pointed out that mass-market shoe sellers measure shoe size, asking why they did not separately measure the arch if the problem were severe: “aapka Adidas, Reebok, Nike ya jo bhi Bata jo ki mass pe joote bechte hain, woh sirf size kyun naapte hain ki aapka ji 10 number hai, aapka 9 number hai.”
I said I had not seen shoe companies offer a sock-like product or another product that treats the arch curve as a separate issue: “Woh ek aise koi sock type banate hain, kuch banate hain aur bolte hain ki nahi number ek cheez hai aur aapka yeh arch curve ka alag cheez hai.”
Peyush Bansal said customized insoles should be made affordable and available everywhere: “Isko affordable banana, har jagah pahunchana.”
Peyush Bansal said Colour Me Mad was on the wrong track: “Aap na galat track pe ho.”
Peyush Bansal questioned why the founders had entered the shoe business: “Aap pata nahi joote mein kyun ghus gaye.”
Peyush Bansal said the founders should make the company a sole business and said it could become very large: “aapko isko na sole business banana chahiye. Itna bada business ban sakta hai.”
Peyush Bansal said he was out of the opportunity: “Toh main aaj isse bahar hoon.”
Namita Thapar said she needed a substantial stake: “I need to have a substantial stake.”
I discussed Colour Me Mad on Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 33. This page records my own remarks separately from the other panelists’ comments; Peyush Bansal’s recommendations and Namita Thapar’s remarks are attributed to them.
I appeared on the Colour Me Mad pitch in Shark Tank India, Season 1, Episode 33.
I said I had never seen a separate arch measurement and did not regard it as a mass problem: “Toh maine toh aaj tak kabhi nahi dekha aisa kuch hai ki arch ka ek measurement hai. Toh toh yeh mass problem nahi hai matlab.”
I did not understand the problem and said a large player would be solving it if it were significant: “Mere ko abhi samajh nahi aayi problem. Hoti toh koi solve kar raha hota bada.”
I said the shoe industry was very large and highly organized, and I doubted the founders could solve the problem even if it were genuine and awareness grew: “Woh joota bahut badi industry hai, usme bahut hi zyada organized players hain. Agar yeh genuine problem hogi aur awareness badhegi bhi, aap nahi solve kar payenge isko.”
I expected customers to trust and choose the insole from the shoe brand they already wore: “main Adidas ka hi insole loonga” and “mere ko uske insole pe zyada trust hoga rather than agar aap kuch bana lete hain.”
I declined the opportunity: “Toh is kaaran se main out hoon.” I said I was out because I did not understand the problem, questioned whether it was a mass problem, and doubted the founders could compete with organized shoe companies and the trust customers placed in their existing shoe brands.
Peyush Bansal recommended focusing only on affordable, high-quality customized insoles and stopping shoe sales and fashion activity: “Aapka mere hisab se customized insole, affordable price, best quality, aapko khali yahi karna chahiye. Yeh sab baaki band kar dena chahiye joote bechna, fashion mein ghusna.”
Peyush Bansal recommended making the best-quality, cheapest sole, automating production, establishing its supply chain, and tying up with shoe companies that could earn margin on the insole: “Sabse badhiya sole, sabse sasta banana aur uski supply chain set karna ki kaise aap usko automation se banayein. Saare shoe wale chahe woh Adidas ho, chahe woh Nike ho, chahe woh Bata ho, aap unse tie-up kariye, woh aapka insole unko margin milega.”
Peyush Bansal suggested raising “4-5 million dollar.”
Peyush Bansal recommended building an engineering team and giving a tech co-founder “20-30-40% equity.”
Namita Thapar said, “25 is good enough for me to get what I need to get. I need to have a substantial stake.” The excerpt does not specify what the 25 refers to or give complete offer terms.
I urged the founders to accept, warning that their shoes would wear out and they might not get as good an offer: “Main aapko bata raha hoon aapke joote ghis jayenge, itna achha offer nahi milega, kar lo aap.” I had called it a good offer: “It's a good offer.”
I said “4 saal se” during the exchange. The excerpt does not explain what the four years referred to.