I also set out startup-policy proposals covering a single window for licenses and filings across SEBI, RBI, FEMA, IT, GST, and local authorities, with a maximum 15-day ETA and default approval if that ETA is breached.
My proposals included taxing employees’ ESOP capital gains only when an actual cash gain is realised, rather than when the grant is exercised, and counting capital-gain tenure from vesting.
I proposed allowing domestic investors to write off investment in any startup at any time as per their discretion (without needing to dispose of shares).
I proposed that any subsequent capital gain on the same investment thereafter be taxed in full, assuming an investment cost as ₹0.
I described these proposals as “the top 3.”
I have commented on ESOP taxation by comparing the cost of exercising Zomato options with the market price, describing how I understand the exercise-to-sale period, and challenging a claim about short-term capital gains and real-estate benefits.
I said that if someone exercised a Zomato ESOP at “₹140 or higher price post IPO,” they probably paid more per share in Income Tax than the price at which shares could then be bought in the market.
I put the market price at “₹56 / share price” and joked that markets were giving everyone ESOPs.
I said that most people would pay a marginal tax rate “upto 45% (incl surcharge),” rather than 28% LTCG, under the Indian tax treatment I was describing.
I gave the reason as the relevant period being “between exercise and sale” rather than from the grant of the ESOPs.
I questioned what real-estate investment benefit applies to short-term capital gains and told the other person to understand ESOP taxation first.
I called for the government to abolish Capital Gains Tax.
I argued that “These markets aren’t going to correct by themselves” and that they “need structural change.”
Related: startup funding and share sales, startup investor returns, employment and work norms