I argue that Indian companies, especially IT services firms, should move beyond contract work and man-hour sales toward owning intellectual property and technology. I use Sun Pharma’s Organon acquisition and Tata Motors’ JLR purchase as examples of moves toward higher-value ownership.
Sun Pharma bought Organon this week for $11.75 billion.
The Organon purchase was all cash.
For two decades, Sun was India's smartest generics player. Its model was to wait for an American patent to expire, manufacture cheaper, and sell everywhere.
Organon changes the math for Sun Pharma by adding: Branded women's health, biosimilars, original IP.
Tata Motors bought JLR from Ford for $2.3 billion.
Today JLR is the biggest engine of Tata Motors' profits, as I put it in my post.
I described Indian IT services as having run for 30 years.
I criticized the industry’s model this way: Stayed contract manufacturers. Smarter, bigger, but still selling man-hours.
I said Indian IT services now face an existential #AI question.
I argued that TCS, Infosys and Wipro should have made this strategic shift a decade back.
My ambition is: We need our biggest cos to sit at the top of the value-creation pyramid, where IP and technology sit.
I said India's future depends on this shift toward the top of the value-creation pyramid.
I used the phrase “Made for Bharat,” without explaining what it referred to.
I asked whether Indian entrepreneurs could build Google-equivalent technology and reach the same business scale if Google were not present in India; I called it “a bit of a trick question” because an Indian runs Google.
In a post discussing which city is India’s tech capital, I wrote, “We also have water 💦😎”. The post quoted @aakrit’s statement that four entities were Mumbai-born and headquartered; their identities are not specified in the captured post.
I clarified that my argument was not that India has no tech companies: “Most companies in India are tech-enabled. Not many are pure tech.” I said company characteristics, not the “xTech” label, determine a company’s nature.
I described real tech as “Software or digital goods → close to zero marginal cost of replication,” with high gross margins and minimal COGS, network effects and scale with minimal capital, and proprietary IP or infrastructure too capital-intensive to beat.
I named social media, AI, search, SaaS, matchmaking, and gaming as real-tech areas, and ShareChat, Whatfix, BrowserStack, Shaadi.com, Dream11, and AgniKul Cosmos as examples.
I described tech-enabled businesses this way: “Real goods → lower gross margins”; they require operations, logistics, supply chains, and people, making them tougher to scale, while competitive intensity can erode margins over time.
I placed D2C brands, product and service marketplaces, proptech, logistics, and most edtech players in the tech-enabled category, naming Cars24, Unacademy, Wakefit, and Swiggy as examples. I said they use tech, but tech is not their product.
I said the confusion between the categories exists because the multiples are better. I called an ad positioning a real-estate developer as a “leading consumer tech company” “cosplay,” not tech.
I wrote that, depending on growth and margins, tech trades at 5-20X revenue while tech-enabled trades at 2-5X in most cases.
I proposed a one-metric test: if a company cannot hit 30%+ op margin at scale, it is probably building with tech rather than building tech.
I said both kinds of businesses are valuable for India, but argued that more founders should focus on pure-tech companies rather than tech-washing if we want to build global companies from India quickly. I said I already see this shift, especially with AI in India.
My posts connect pride in building for India with questions about India’s entrepreneurial potential and a framework for distinguishing companies that build technology from companies that use it.
Related: digital sovereignty and dependence, deep tech and space, indias innovation ambitions