On 2024-11-14 05:32 UTC, I posted a complaint about traffic-camera enforcement and the grievance process, tagging @mieknathshinde and @MTPHereToHelp.
I said, “Cameras in the traffic hands of cops have been weaponised,” describing my view of police use of traffic cameras.
I described the camera activity as “Random clicks of license plates” and claimed there was “0 evidence.”
I claimed the random license-plate clicks resulted in “thousands in fines every month.”
I said, “To resolve u are asked to file a grievance,” describing the route people are told to use when seeking a resolution.
I said “no1 ever replies” to grievances and tagged @mieknathshinde and @MTPHereToHelp.
I ended with the direct appeal, “Kya hoga sir aam aadmi ka”.
These are my allegations and concerns from the post; it does not identify specific incidents or locations, provide supporting evidence, name the grievance-processing authority, or specify a remedy I sought from the tagged accounts.
I have argued that traffic enforcement needs safeguards: automated penalties can be difficult to challenge, especially when the evidence is unclear and people lack time to contest them.
I said an acquaintance recently received an online traffic penalty for not wearing a helmet, despite owning a car.
I said, “Every month we also get auto-penalised by @MTPHereToHelp adding up to thousands for a couple of cars.”
I said, “Photos shared as evidence often have just the license plates”.
I said, “we don’t have the time to fight this out in Lok Adalat, like most others.”
I said “the traffic menace does need interventions” and warned that “weaponising it without safeguards can become harassment.”
I proposed, “Maybe dept pays citizens 2x if they can’t prove the violation”.
I also objected to traffic lights being switched to manual mode whenever it rains, saying this creates chaos and confusion on the road, and asked for a protocol change. The post does not describe a replacement protocol.
I said, “create complete chaos and confusion on the road” about switching traffic lights to manual mode whenever it rains.
A separate post praised @MTPHereToHelp for responding quickly and restoring traffic lights. The post quoted my rain-related complaint and request for a protocol change; the quoted request is not a claim made by the praising post’s author.
The post reported that “Impressive how quickly @MTPHereToHelp responded & restored traffic lights”.
In a later complaint, the post reported a “fine of 1500 rs” “for obstruction of traffic” and said the “photo taken as evidence only shows the license plate.”
The November complaint questions whether a fine is justified when the evidence photo shows only a license plate. Its quoted passage repeats my earlier concern about automatic penalties and safeguards, but adds no independently established evidence about those cases.
I asked, “Why go to manual mode every time it rains” and said, “Bhai, traffic lights ko apna kaam karne do🚦”.
I asked @MTPHereToHelp, “Protocol change karo pls 🙏🏼” about rain-time traffic signals.
I asked, “How is this ok?” about the reported fine of 1500 rs for obstruction of traffic when the photo taken as evidence only shows the license plate.
Related: mumbai traffic, platform market harms and accountability, cricket governance