I see app-store fees and control over app distribution as a threat to startup economics and to the open Internet. My posts connect the costs of acquiring distribution with the power Apple and Google exercise over app developers.
I said many startups pay anywhere between 20-50% as Google Tax to get distribution and protect their own brand from bidders.
I characterized this as “the Digital East India Company” and expressed sadness about it with 😥.
I argued that Apple and Google were trying to move the open Internet into a closed app ecosystem where they could lord over the Internet economy, and said they wanted 100% dominance.
I said Google wanted to charge app developers anywhere between 11-30% if they had a premium service.
I said developers would file a tax return with Google every month so Google could audit and charge them.
I argued that the proposed charge came on top of the 20-50% of revenue developers already spend to get distribution on the Play store, and that the combined burden would be 60-70% of our revenue.
In my March 4 reply, I argued that the added charge would leave developers with 60-70% of our revenue and make companies viable only if they paid these taxes.
The account replying to me disagreed with the quoted claim that companies would only be viable if they paid the taxes, responding: “cos will NOT be viable.”
The reply quoted my claims about the existing distribution spend and the combined burden; its brief response was the replying account’s view, not mine.
I challenged the infrastructure justification, saying that Google simply provides a link from the apk and provides no infra to app developers.
I argued that Google was charging for payment gateway services at 20 times the market rate I cited as 1%.
I compared Google’s desired payment-gateway charge with a market rate of 1% and described the comparison as 20x.
I disputed Google’s account of the court and regulator proceedings, saying that both of them have admitted our petitions for non-compliance with CCI's earlier order.
I said 97% of the 200k apps Google described as compliant were free, so they had no question of compliance.
I alleged that Google delisted cos that sought legal relief, describing it as an act of vengeance.
I said apps that were restored had no billing feature and that this was almost as good as not having the app.
I proposed 2 solutions: immediate intervention against bundling at the device or customer end, and long-term unbundling of Google and Apple services so users could choose their default app store and apps.
I proposed that developers should be free to choose third-party payment gateways, while Google could still provide its own payment services.
For the immediate solution, I said developers should be free to choose 3rd party PGs and Google should have no rights to ask for P&Ls; I said the government should handle that oversight.
I warned that without safeguards, companies could end up controlling our economic future.
I warned that without appropriate safeguards, companies could control India's economic future, while saying India had a strong and proactive government.
I said 97% of the 200k apps were free, so there was no question of compliance for them; I also alleged that some companies complied under duress and that Google delisted companies seeking legal relief.
I said apps Google restored had no billing feature, calling that almost as good as not having the app.
I called for intervention to prevent Google from bundling services at the device or customer end.
I said Google should have no right to ask developers for P&Ls, adding that the government should handle that oversight.
For the long term, I proposed unbundling Google and Apple services so users could choose the default App Store and apps on their phones.
I left it to readers to decide whether Google is evil rather than giving a yes-or-no answer.
I said India had changed and had a strong, proactive government that would not fall for Big Tech’s lies, deceit, or manipulation of the judiciary.
I ended my post with “Jai Hind 🇮🇳.”
I left the question of whether Google was evil for readers to decide rather than giving a yes-or-no answer.
In a separate post introducing the thread, I asked “Is Google evil?” and invited readers to understand the core of the issue.
In a reply to my thread, I again described Apple and Google’s effort to move the open Internet into a closed app ecosystem and repeated the claims about 11-30% charges for premium services and monthly tax returns to Google.
Related: google app delistings and restorations, digital infrastructure and access, platform market harms and accountability