I see AI, human capability, and productivity as connected questions: software may be transformed by AI, while human judgment and creativity remain distinct from the kinds of work AI already handles well.
I wrote, “AI is eating software is eating the world.”
@Sb11539292591 posted that the subject would “will decrease human productivity.” The captured post does not identify what subject would have that effect.
@Sb11539292591 also predicted that the subject would “massively increase capital productivity.” The captured post does not identify the subject.
I asked, “Is AI about to replace humans?” and answered, “Not anytime soon.”
I argued that matching one human brain with today’s AI approaches would require something close to a football-field-sized data centre running flat out to mimic how one person sees, thinks, learns, and decides in real time.
I contrasted that resource demand with a brain operating on 20 watts.
I wrote that biological replication involving neurons, synapses, chemistry, and plasticity would theoretically require “a computer the size of planet Earth 🌍”.
I described AI as exceptional at “automation, repetition, and pattern extraction at scale.”
I distinguished those strengths from human “judgment, creativity, context, taste, and knowing when 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘵𝘰 𝘢𝘤𝘵,” which I said are not simply a matter of adding more parameters.
I attributed those abilities to processes evolved over millions of years and to emergent properties of a system that learns continuously, reasons across domains, and compresses reality with extreme efficiency.
In my view, replacing human creativity is not a near-term threat until there is a fundamental shift in how intelligence is computed, rather than just bigger models and more GPUs.
My comparison distinguishes computationally mimicking a brain from attempting biological replication. I did not provide calculations or technical assumptions for the data-centre or planet-sized-computer comparisons, define a timeframe for “not anytime soon,” or specify what fundamental shift would change my conclusion.
Related: human judgment in ai work, ai jobs and regulation, work hours and balance