I remember my exchange during Cookie Cartel’s pitch on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 21. The lines marked [me] are my word-for-word Hinglish remarks; the lines marked [other] belong to the founders or other Sharks and are context, not my words or views.
The pitch I’m recording here was Cookie Cartel on Shark Tank India, Season 5, Episode 21.
The founders presented “The Scarface and Notorious Blackie,” and I asked whether they had written the names themselves: “The Scarface and Notorious Blackie. You wrote these yourself?”
My cookie texture preference was that I dislikes hard cookies and prefers very soft ones: “Mujhe na woh hard cookies bohot kharab lagte hain. Mujhe hamesha woh jo bilkul soft wale hote hain”
I praised the writing of The Scarface and Notorious Blackie and complimented the taste: “Bohot accha likha hai” and “Nahin nahin, taste bhi bohot accha hai.”
The founder described oxygen-barrier packaging nitrogen-flushed to retain freshness: “oxygen-barrier packaging hai which have been nitrogen-flushed to retain that freshness that you are seeing.”
The basic dark-and-white-chocolate cookie cost ₹190: “woh ₹190 ki cookie hai.”
The most expensive cookie cost ₹330 and had different fillings: “the most expensive cookie is at ₹330 jis mein alag-alag fillings hote hain.”
I said the price range seemed high and customers might hesitate before trying: “Price range toh bohot higher side hua na thoda?” and “Jab tak koi khareedega nahi tab tak pata nahi lagega ki isme taste kya hai. Toh khareedne se pehle log do baar sochenge ki itna kyun”.
The founder said the ingredients included couverture chocolate, premium fillings, and two different flours: “hum log couverture chocolate waapar rahe hain, the best premium fillings as well, we are also using a certain amount of flour, combination of two different flours”.
The founder estimated about ₹3.5 crores in sales for the year: “Is saal we are estimated to do about ₹3.5 crores.”
The founder expected a 20% loss for the year: “Loss rahega is saal 20%.” The exchange does not establish the precise scope or basis of that loss.
The company’s stated growth sequence was to capture its cloud-kitchen market first, then move into retail: “we want to first capture that market and then shift into the retail space.”
I said my investment Cinnamon Kitchen had recently seen a strong spike, mainly because of quick commerce: “Suddenly itna spike bohot accha aaraha hai because of quick commerce mainly.” I suggested Cookie Cartel’s sales could double if it entered that channel; this was my suggestion, not a reported result.
The founder said Blinkit required at least 3 months of shelf life: “we should have it at least for 3 months.” I disagreed that the requirement was necessarily at least 3 months: “Nahi nahi, aisa nahi hai.”
Vineeta Singh noted that bread was being sold. The founder’s following Bangalore remark is incomplete—“Bangalore not itself just in”—so I do not treat it as a complete claim.
Namita went out; she lacked confidence in execution rigor at scale and the prospect of moving from losses to profits and investor exit. Her remarks included: “Yeh business mein jo ek execution rigor hai, that is going to be the make or break” and “mujhe woh execution play pe confidence nahi hai, and that is the reason I am out.”
I praised Hisham’s branding, positioning, and command of his game, but doubted Hisham's speed of execution after his answer about not entering Blinkit: “Mujhe tere speed of execution capabilities pe thoda doubt aaraha hai abhi.”
I went out; I thought Hisham did not need the money and wanted to invest where there was need: “And I don't think you need the money, frankly. Mujhe aisa lag raha hai tere paas paise hain, aur meko apne paise wahan daalne hain jahan zaroorat hai. For that reason, unfortunately, I'll be out now.”
After the founder asked, “Could we do 12% for ₹80 lakhs?”, I joked, “Kar lo yaar, ₹5 lakh de do.” This was a joke; no formal offer or completed deal is established. The founder’s proposed terms were 12% for ₹80 lakhs, and my remark does not establish a formal counteroffer.
The exchange leaves open the basis for the founder’s stated 20% loss; the context of Namita’s reference to “₹3.5 crore sales in 3 years”; what the founder meant by the incomplete Bangalore remark; whether the 12% for ₹80 lakhs was a formal counteroffer or led to later negotiation; and Cookie Cartel’s actual repeat-purchase rate, shelf life, and quick-commerce eligibility. I said repeat was high, but no figure was given.
I closed by saying goodbye to Hisham: “See you. Bye bye, Hisham. Bye.”
Namita supplied “Gooey” as the word for the cookie texture: “Gooey, the word is gooey. Very gooey, yes, gooey.”
Hisham said the branding created curiosity with people: “Par jo humari branding hai woh bhi ek cheez hai jo, which creates a curiosity with people.”
I said Cookie Cartel’s repeat was high: “Aapka repeat high hai”