I have argued that colleges should give students more agency in choosing their fields of study after admission. I question rank-based stream allocation and the status hierarchy it can create, and I compare college choices with how the work world matches skills and interests to jobs.
I asked, “Why do incoming students in many leading 🇮🇳 colleges have to pick their stream based on their entrance exam rank?”
I argued: “Given the entrance exam is the same for everyone, it doesn't indicate a student's aptitude or interest one way or the other for a particular stream.”
My recommendation was: “Once they are in, they should get to decide whichever stream they want to pursue.”
I argued: “With the diversity and ubiquity of opportunities to innovate in today's world, no particular stream should be put on a pedestal, creating an unnecessary hierarchy of purported intellectual superiority/inferiority (something students have to often live with for a long time even after graduating).”
I drew an analogy with employment: “The "work world" believes so strongly in matching skills and interests to jobs. Why is that logic not applied in colleges?”
I acknowledged the objection that “Many will say that if this is done then everyone will opt for computer science and there will be a staffing and resource imbalance in colleges.”
In response, I pointed to the demand for innovation and talent across fields: “all of these and more are demonstrating a voracious, unprecedented appetite for innovation and absorbing top talent.”
I concluded by asking: “Hence, is it time for the colleges to finally ask themselves this important question?”
Related: schools and education systems, young startup founders, ai and career change